The Caleb Davidson Barn - an essay

The Caleb Davidson barn, constructed in 1839, is situated on the gently rolling prairie of Woodford County, Illinois, just a stone's throw from the waters of Walnut Creek. This was the location where the pioneer community of Walnut Grove (later Eureka) arose as pioneer families from several counties in Kentucky, who shared common abolitionist sympathies, made their long trek to the free state of Illinois in the early-1830s. In addition to their antislavery views, these early residents were also united by a common faith as they were founding members of the Christian Church (Disciples of Christ) community that had its origins in Kentucky. One local historian has written of these early settlers: “Their chief aim was not great wealth but civilization. So, while they built their homes they helped build school houses and churches, sometimes living in dwellings lacking conveniences so that they might provide the other necessities of civilization.”

...continued from Home page.

The Davidson barn was one of the largest structures constructed in the early settlement of Walnut Grove, and it quickly became a community gathering place. In addition to its primary utility as a barn, the structure became a de-facto community center in the early decades of the settlement, and a variety of events took place within the structure. Both Barton W. Stone and Alexander Campbell, co-founders of the Christian Church (Disciples of Christ) movement, each visited the community of Walnut Grove and it is believed that both conducted church services within the confines of the Davidson barn. In so doing, these early church leaders converted the threshing floor of the barn into sacred space as they brought the message of spiritual transformation to the early residents of the community. A few years later, Abraham Lincoln hitched his horse in the barn while visiting with the Davidson family to discuss matters related to a pending case. Lincoln frequently came through the area as an attorney riding the Eighth Judicial District circuit and attending to cases at the nearby courthouse in Metamora, Illinois.

The Davidson barn, which is the oldest surviving structure in Eureka, Illinois, connects the community to its pioneer past, but it is currently in severe need of preservation if these valuable heritage links are to be maintained. Local efforts are underway to preserve and restore the barn, likely by dismantling it and relocating it to a different site, so that this historical and architectural treasure can endure and benefit future generations.

Relocating and restoring the Davidson barn will permit the possibility of repurposing of the structure to take place. Although a final decision has not been determined, suggested uses of the structure might include space for a museum, a chapel, classrooms, or community meeting rooms. Any efforts to repurpose the structure would be done in an aesthetically appropriate fashion that would accentuate the unique architectural design of the superstructure. Just as pioneer families found multiple uses for this common space, contemporary users of the structure would also find it to be conducive to a variety of functions and purposes.

From outside appearances, the Davidson barn appears to be worn and in disrepair as its façade and roof have weathered both the ravages of time and exposure to the elements. Yet, upon closer inspection, it becomes clear that the hand-hewn beams that constitute the superstructure of the barn remain solid and provide a steadfast foundation for all that has transpired within the space. Much like an extended metaphor for the local community and the individuals who constitute it, the foundations of the structure are solid and enduring and that which is superficial can be repaired and made right again. As such, this historic site that is an invaluable part of our cultural legacy continues to remind us of our own faith journey and the power of transformation.

Junius P. Rodriguez
Professor of History
Eureka College